Demographic Deities
A Reply to Robert L. Sharp’s “Talking about Religion”
By Fr. David Thatcher
I found myself perplexed as I read Robert L. Sharp’s opinion piece, “Talking about Religion” (April 25, 2009). On the one hand, Mr. Sharp has enough interest in the topic of religious faith that he would bother to write about it — even “with extreme trepidation.” On the other hand, he ends his column describing himself as neither agnostic nor atheist, but rather as an apatheist – an invented word, playing off the word apathy, meaning one who does cares not about the matter of God. So, Mr. Sharp writes about religion and God, but doesn’t really care about it or people who do. How one puts these two things together with any degree of seriousness? Surely matters of God, faith, and culture are serious questions. Nevertheless, Mr. Sharp’s statements on these things are quite public, and whatever his personal journey has been, he is worthy of a response.
Mr. Sharp’s criticisms of religion and such are, actually, cultural criticisms. He doesn’t directly address the matter of whether or not any particular religion’s beliefs are true or not, other than to cavalierly brush such aside by defining faith as beyond evidence of any kind — that it is always simply blind faith. (I’m not sure why Mr. Sharp felt the need to cite a Professor of Electrical Engineering in this; many have tried to define faith in such a manner.)
There are two assumptions about such an approach to faith, neither of which is, in the end, defensible. First, while I am not expert on world religions, as a pastor of the Orthodox Christian Church I can assure Mr. Sharp and his authorities that Christianity in fact makes claims about truth — and wants to be judged on this basis. Faith is no mere leap in the dark; there are reasons to believe in the gospel. . . . .